A Giant Among Horse Fossils Rises from the Arctic Permafrost to Revise Evolutionary Theory

In your imagination, what do prehistoric horses look like? For most of us, it means a hooved animal about the size of a fox. The diminutive size of fossil horses in natural history museums and our equine science textbooks tells us how tiny they were. But now, maybe we should revise that image because not all ancient horses were tiny. To prove that point, Canadian researchers have found a veritable giant among horse fossiles deep in the Arctic frost.

Dr Duane Froese of the University of Alberta with a horse skull fossil found in Arctic permafrost. (Grant Zazula photo)

When University of Alberta researcher?Duane Froese found such an unusually large horse fossil in the Yukon permafrost in northern Canada, he knew it was important. Now, in a new study published in the journal?Nature, this fossil’s DNA is rewriting the story of equine evolution.

Froese, a researcher in the?Department of Earth and Atmospheric Sciences and Canada Research Chair in Northern Environmental Change at the University, had spent years visiting Yukon to understand the permafrost and the ice age environments that supported megafauna including mammoths, horses and bison.

And he wasn’t alone. A National Science Foundation grant from the United States government and an elite group of researchers and students made sure that this fossil wouldn’t get away.

Unlike the small ice age horse fossils that are common across the unglaciated areas of the Yukon, Alaska and Siberia, and which date to the last hundred thousand years, this fossil was at least the size of a modern domestic horse. Froese had seen these large horses only a few times at much older (geologically speaking)?sites in the region?but none were so remarkably well preserved in permafrost.

The scientists dated the permafrost at the site from volcanic ashes in the deposits and knew that it was about 700,000 years old?representing some of the oldest known ice in the Northern Hemisphere. They also knew the fossil was similarly old.

Frozen DNA yields oldest genome on record

On a hunch, the team extracted collagen from the fossil and found it had preserved blood proteins and that short fragments of ancient DNA were present within the bone. The DNA showed that the horse fell outside the diversity of all modern and ancient horse DNA ever sequenced consistent with its geologic age.

After several years of work, a draft genome of this horse was assembled and is providing new insight into the evolution of horses.

Yukon paleontologist Grant Zazula, a contributor to the study, showed that the horse fell within a line of horses that includes all modern horses and the last remaining truly wild horses, the Przewalski’s horse from the Mongolian Steppes of Central Asia. Zazula notes that the discovery of the fossil “is testament to the remarkable archive of natural history in Canadian permafrost.”

Also remarkable was that the ancient DNA survived so long. “It bends, if not breaks, the rules that govern DNA decay and pushes back the time in which DNA is recoverable by nearly an order of magnitude,” said Beth Shapiro, an evolutionary biologist and ancient DNA expert at the University of California, Santa Cruz, and a collaborator in the study. “Had it not been frozen for the entire duration of that 700,000 years, I doubt that any recoverable DNA would have survived.”

The 700,000-year-old horse genome?along with the genome of a 43,000-year-old horse, six present-day horses and a donkey?has allowed the research team to estimate how fast mutations accumulate through time.

This work, led by researchers from the University of Copenhagen, has revealed that the last common ancestor of all modern equids (including donkeys, horses and zebras) lived about 4 million to 4.5 million years ago?an evolutionary timeline reaching back twice as long as previously thought.

In addition, the new genomes revealed episodes of severe demographic fluctuations in horse populations in phase with major climatic changes, including severe losses in diversity during previous warm periods in the Arctic and when horses were domesticated.


Evolutionary mystery solved

The results also solved a long-standing mystery about the evolutionary origin of Przewalski’s horse. This horse population?which shows striking physical differences from domesticated horses, including an extra pair of chromosomes?was discovered by the Western world in the second half of the nineteenth century and rapidly became threatened. These horses were almost extinct in the wild by the mid-1950s but survived after massive conservation efforts.

The researchers revealed that the Przewalski’s horse population was isolated from the lineage leading to present-day domesticated horses about 50,000 years ago. They also showed that pure Przewalski’s horse lineages are still living today. This suggests that the Przewalski’s horse is likely genetically viable and therefore worthy of conservation.

According to news provided by the University of California, the study also identified genomic regions in domestic horse breeds that show low levels of genetic variation compared to the Przewalski horse and could correspond to genetic variants selected early on in the domestication process.

“In order to really tease out the evolutionary changes associated with horse domestication, we need to know where the genes are in the genome and what they do, which means we need a better annotated genome of the modern horse,” Shapiro said. “But using these older genomes is a great start–it can point us to regions of the genome that appear to have been evolving under selection for tens or even hundreds of thousands of years. Now we just have to figure out why.”

Thanks to the University of Alberta news service for sharing this story with The Jurga Report (used with permission).




Related Posts

Gray horse head in profile on EQ Extra 89 cover
What we’ve learned about PPID
Do right by your retired horse
Tame your horse’s anxiety
COVER EQ_EXTRA-VOL86 Winter Care_fnl_Page_1
Get ready for winter!


"*" indicates required fields


Additional Offers

Additional Offers
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.